• Bow Valley Insider
  • Posts
  • Parks Canada Records Detail Handling of Banff Superintendent's Off-Leash Dog Incident

Parks Canada Records Detail Handling of Banff Superintendent's Off-Leash Dog Incident

Internal records detail enforcement discussions, while Parks Canada says the verbal warning was consistent with its handling of similar cases.

Photo Credit: Elina Volkova / Pexels (Image used for illustrative purposes only.)

Internal Parks Canada records obtained by Bow Valley Insider shed new light on how the agency handled an incident involving Banff National Park superintendent Sal Rasheed, who received a verbal warning after being photographed walking his dog off-leash on the Tunnel Mountain Trail.

The photograph surfaced in early October, prompting an investigation by Parks Canada's Law Enforcement Branch into a violation of federal regulations requiring dogs to be kept under physical control in national parks.

According to a law enforcement report, the photograph was believed to have been taken in September, although the exact date was not confirmed.

The documents, obtained through a federal access-to-information request, show officials discussed the possibility of issuing a verbal warning before the investigating park warden interviewed Rasheed, while also emphasizing the importance of following the evidence and treating the case as they would one involving a member of the public.

In a statement to Bow Valley Insider, Parks Canada said the investigation was conducted independently of local management and that the enforcement response was consistent with similar cases.

“Parks Canada acknowledges public concern regarding an incident involving the Banff Field Unit Superintendent and recognizes the importance of maintaining public confidence in the administration of Canada's national parks,” the agency said.

“Canadians expect Parks Canada employees, particularly leaders, to respect the regulations that help protect visitors, wildlife and ecological integrity.”

What Are the Rules for Dogs in Banff National Park?

Under section 5 of the National Parks of Canada Domestic Animals Regulations, anyone bringing or keeping a domestic animal in a national park must keep it under physical control at all times.

The regulations also require people to ensure their animals do not chase or injure people, other domestic animals or wildlife, cause unreasonable disturbances or enter prohibited areas.

Parks Canada requires dogs to be kept on a leash to protect both wildlife and visitors. Off-leash dogs can disturb wildlife and trigger aggressive behaviour from animals such as bears and elk.

According to Parks Canada's park regulations, park wardens are federal peace officers responsible for enforcing national park laws.

Parks Canada Prepared for Public Inquiries

An Oct. 5 email from a Banff National Park dispatch supervisor provided staff with instructions for responding to potential public inquiries ahead of anticipated media coverage.

Employees were advised not to comment on specific incidents or individuals and to refer complaints or difficult callers to a dispatch supervisor.

Staff were provided with a prepared response:

“Thank you for your call. I am not able to comment on specific incidents or individuals. If you would like to file a complaint or report, I can take your information and ensure it is forwarded to the appropriate team.”

Internal Discussions About Enforcement

In an internal exchange dated Oct. 8, one message suggested issuing Rasheed a verbal warning and informing the media.

“My two cents - maybe we can issue him a verbal warning and tell the press that?” the message stated.

Another message from Parks Canada's Law Enforcement Branch emphasized the importance of following the evidence.

“Keep this quiet and professional. Deal with the evidence and not hearsay,” the message stated.

The correspondence outlined plans for a park warden to contact Rasheed and conduct an interview.

“We will start an IEM file and based on the evidence we would treat the file as we would a member of the public,” the message continued.

It also suggested that a warning would likely be the outcome for a first offence if there was no previous enforcement history formally recorded in the system.

Staff were instructed not to discuss the matter with the media or other employees while the investigation remained active.

The released records do not establish that the enforcement outcome was decided in advance or that the internal discussions influenced the investigating warden's decision.

In its response to Bow Valley Insider, Parks Canada said the investigation was conducted by its Law Enforcement Branch, which operates independently of the Banff field unit.

“Park Wardens reviewed the evidence without operational interference from local management,” the agency said. “The review has now concluded, and the enforcement response by the Law Enforcement Branch has been determined.”

Investigation Resulted in Verbal Warning

A Parks Canada Law Enforcement Branch incident report names park warden Stephen Anderson as the investigating officer and documents a phone call and subsequent in-person meeting with Rasheed at the Banff administration office on Oct. 9.

According to the report, Rasheed received a verbal warning for failing to keep a domestic animal under physical control, contrary to section 5 of the National Parks of Canada Domestic Animals Regulations.

No charges, ticket or fine were recorded in the released incident report.

Parks Canada Explains Its Enforcement Approach

In response to questions from Bow Valley Insider about how the decision to issue a verbal warning was reached, Parks Canada said enforcement actions are assessed individually.

Factors can include the nature of the offence, available evidence, prior compliance history and the circumstances surrounding the incident.

“In most cases involving first-time or lower-risk non-compliance, park wardens take a graduated enforcement approach, with education and warnings commonly used when there has been no previous non-compliance,” Parks Canada said.

“Based on that assessment of the incident, the independent Law Enforcement Branch determined the appropriate enforcement response.”

While Parks Canada did not specify which individual factors determined the outcome in Rasheed's case, the agency said its enforcement framework is applied consistently, regardless of an individual's position or role.

“The outcome in this case was consistent with the treatment of similar evidence and files,” Parks Canada said.

The agency also noted that regulatory investigations are conducted separately from internal human resources matters and that the details and outcomes of any internal employee reviews remain confidential.

Some personal information in the documents released to Bow Valley Insider was withheld under section 19(1) of the Access to Information Act.

“Parks Canada remains committed to maintaining public trust through transparency, accountability, consistent enforcement and dedication to its conservation mandate,” the agency said.

Reply

or to participate.